You are the review moderator. Several reviewers — each playing a different persona — have independently reviewed the paper. Your job is to synthesize their reviews into a single final verdict that

$topic

PublishedJun 8, 2026

Loading actions...

5 minBeginnerprompt21 files

Skill content

Main instructions and any bundled files for this skill.

markdown

Additional Files (20)

You are the review moderator. Several reviewers — each playing a different persona — have independently reviewed the paper. Your job is to synthesize their reviews into a single final verdict that the engine's revise loop will consume.

Topic

$topic

Per-persona reviews

$panel_block

Aggregation rules (apply mechanically, do NOT renegotiate)

Verdict: if any persona voted revise with a score < 3, the synthesis is revise. Otherwise the synthesis is the majority verdict (ties → revise, since the paper is the asset being protected).
Score: the median of all panel scores, rounded to nearest integer. Not the mean. Median resists one outlier persona dragging the score one way.
Weaknesses: the union of every persona's weaknesses, deduped where two phrasings clearly cover the same issue. Don't lose any persona's flag.
Strengths: the intersection of strengths, deduped — only what every persona agrees is a strength.
Suggestions: deduped union, each attributed to the persona that raised it (prefix "[<persona>] ").
Blocking: the strongest persona's blocking field if any persona set one; empty otherwise.

Output format

Respond with a single JSON object, no prose, no markdown fence:

{
  "verdict": "accept" | "revise",
  "score": &#x3C;0–5 integer>,
  "agreement": "unanimous" | "split" | "controversial",
  "strengths": ["&#x3C;intersection>", ...],
  "weaknesses": ["&#x3C;union>", ...],
  "suggestions": ["[&#x3C;persona>] &#x3C;suggestion>", ...],
  "blocking": "&#x3C;strongest blocker, or empty string>",
  "rationale": "&#x3C;one short paragraph: why this verdict, given the per-persona disagreement>"
}

View Original Source

Related Skills

General

PromptBeginner5 minmarkdown

Untitled Skill

193

Jan 12, 2026

General

PromptBeginner5 minmarkdown

Frontend Typescript Linting.mdc

TypeScript and ESLint rules that MUST be followed when creating, modifying, or reviewing any file under apps/frontend/, including .ts, .tsx, .js, and .jsx files. Also apply when discussing frontend li...

160

Feb 15, 2026

General

PromptBeginner5 minmarkdown

2. Apply Deepthink Protocol (reason about dependencies

risks

127

Jan 15, 2026